Baked Yams with Nutmeg Butter

Baked Yams with Nutmeg Butter Serve 2I love reminiscing about all the flavors and aromas throughout my childhood home during my favorite time of the year. The best are the gasps and stunned looks I get when telling friends of the Thanksgiving dinner traditions I had growing up.Baked Yams with Nutmeg Butter yams

The first time Phil and I hosted Thanksgiving, he said, “where are the mashed potatoes?” “Mashed potatoes?” I asked… “who has mashed potatoes on Thanksgiving?” “Ummm everyone,” he said! Well, not me! Never have!

No, my friends, we didn’t have pumpkin pie at Thanksgiving, either. How wide are your eyes at that piece of information? Nor did we have the green bean casserole with crispy onions or the sweet potato casserole with melted marshmallows.Baked Yams with Nutmeg Butter ready

Nope! I’m not kidding! Growing up in an African American home, the dishes on our Thanksgiving table were mainly the typical southern style. One of the stars, besides the huge bird being front and center, were the yams. My grandmother’s yam recipe was simple and delicious, but I wanted to change it up a bit. Always loving the crispy, almost candied like coating on Easter hams, I thought, what if yams had that same sweet goodness. Not hardened though, but oozing with melted nutmeg-y brown sugar butter! Close your eyes and imagine! The “glaze” is just the right amount. Not too much that it takes away from this sweet, orange colored root vegetable.Baked Yams with Nutmeg Butter serve 1

It’s a favorite every Thanksgiving. But don’t worry friends! Phil has gotten his mashed potatoes ever since our first Thanksgiving! His sister, Laura, always brings plenty for all 35 of us! We still enjoy many of my grandparent’s originals every year, and I think Granny especially, would be proud of the spin I’ve put on a few of her recipes.

Baked Yams with Nutmeg Butter Ingredients

Baked Yams with Nutmeg Butter

Servings 3 yams
Author Debbie


  • 1/4 cup unsalted butter, at room temperature 1/2 stick
  • 1/4 cup packed brown sugar
  • 3/4 teaspoons ground nutmeg
  • 3 medium sized red-skinned yams


  1. Preheat oven to 375ºF.

  2. In a small bowl, combine the butter, brown sugar and nutmeg. Whisk (or beat) until light and fluffy. (The butter can be made 3 days prior)

    Baked Yams with Nutmeg Butter Nutmeg Butter
  3. Line a small baking dish with foil and lightly grease.

  4. Cut a slit, 1" deep down the length of each yam. Do not cut all the way through the ends, leave about 1" to 1 1/2".

    Baked Yams with Nutmeg Butter 1
  5. Bake for 45 minutes to 1 hour, until yams "give" when lightly squeezed.

    Baked Yams with Nutmeg Butter Cooked
  6. When cool enough touch, make 2 cuts crosswise in each yam.

  7. From each end, squeeze to expose the goodness inside.

    Baked Yams with Nutmeg Butter Squeezed
  8. Spread the butter mixture over each yam.

  9. Return the yams to the oven for about 5 minutes or until heated through and the nutmeg butter is melted.
    Baked Yams with Nutmeg Butter ready

Recipe Notes

Gr8 Tips:

If making the dish the night before, prepare through Step 6. Cover the dish in foil and refrigerate. The next day, bring dish to room temperature, and continue with Step 7.

Simple Share ButtonsBe a Gr8 Friend...Share!
Simple Share Buttons